Yay! Both of us finally have rings*
This is the shop that we ordered Colin's from. Allison (yes, we have the same name!) makes beautiful jewelry and it arrived timely and in lovely packaging.
My ring came from Gilt. They were also amazing to work with. The woman sat with me as I tried on like twenty different rings. I finally settled on this one, a gorgeous vintage ring from the 1920's.
* There was a small mishap with Colin's first ring. We ordered from an Etsy seller, but the ring just seemed to be set on always being too big. We had it resized twice and still it was a little loose on his finger. Plus, it was really thick/uncomfortable to wear. So instead, I found another one from a different seller on Etsy and replaced it. This one fits just perfect!